Posts Tagged ‘recovery auditing’

Recovery Auditing Misconception #4

Wednesday, April 28th, 2010

Recovery Auditing Misconception #4:   I don’t have the time or resources to support this process

The Short Answer:

It takes very little of your time or resources to support a Lavante recovery audit.  All you need do is send a basic vendor file and dedicate one employee for typically an hour per week.

How is this possible?

To begin an audit: Lavante can get started working from a data file that in many instances requires less than an hour for clients to generate. AP typically can create the data file Lavante needs and client IT does not need to get involved.  This is all that’s required for a full recovery audit.

To support an ongoing audit: Clients working with Lavante typically require less than one hour per week to receive and upload verified claims and vendor file updates into their system. No onsite Lavante personnel are ever needed to support the effort.

Clients who wish to save additional time can work with their Lavante Account Manager to integrate claims directly into their ERP system.  Lavante will automatically match claims against an internal credit listing, thus pre-checking the credits and enabling clients to upload credits directly as ledger entries with no manual intervention.

Lavante InSight

For companies concerned about the time commitment or skeptical of the potential benefits of performing a recovery audit, Lavante offers a way for clients to test and sample the service before fully engaging. 

Lavante InSight™ gives you a view of the recovery audit you might have. It generates an estimate of the likely cash recoveries and vendor updates you will receive if you choose to engage in a Lavante Strategic Recovery audit. Utilizing your master vendor file, InSight leverages Lavante’s extensive database of historical audit detail, a proprietary, on-demand software application and our Supplier Network of over two million companies to develop a comprehensive vendor and recovery analysis. InSight previews potential cash recoveries, duplicate and related vendors, recovery projections over time, vendor updates, and more.

Vendor Credit Recovery

Saturday, April 24th, 2010

Vendor credit benchmarking from the front lines.

Every industry has its fair share of reports, surveys, data points, and sound bites.  The Profit Recovery industry is no different.  In the last few years we have performed quite a bit of analysis and benchmarking to uncovered some compelling data  about recovering credits from your vendors and suppliers.

From a survey of over 100 clients and prospects we have discovered that most traditional recovery providers sample only the top 5-20% of your vendor population when reviewing vendor-side credits?  Our survey elaborates (based on feed back from AP professionals) that without the aid of a communication compliance engine (Lavante is the only firm with such an app.)  traditional statement audit reviews, whether they are done by third party firms or by internal efforts simply cannot support indepth vendor penetration with manual methods and cap out at 20%. 

Our vendor credit recovery benchmarking demonstrates that 61% of vendor credit opportunity resides in the lower 80% of your vendor file.  To put it another way, traditional manual methods, will find, at most, 39% of credits available to you.

Another fact you may not be aware of is that 37% of vendor-side claims come from product returns.  This category is by far the largest we are tracking.  And it has huge implications not only to the existing process you have for returns transactions, but also on where your profit recovery audits should focus.  In contrast, we’ve found that only 9% of vendor-side claims are the result of duplicate payments.  Keep in mind that hese numbers vary depending on industry.   

Some other interesting metrics indicate that the average claim amount from a vendor credit recovery review is $817.  (with a range of about $400-$1200)  We have also discovered that the actual recovery potential for vendor credit recovery is $600,000 -$900,000 per $1Billion in addressable spend volume. Although we are the only recovery provider to project recoveries below the typical industry benchmark ($1M per $1B in spend) we feel confident that this carefully calculated metric passes both the scientific test and a gut test as well.  When we approach new prospects and we explain that depending on their industry they stand to recovery within this range that data is always well received based on what they have actually seen from other firms and not what they have been promised.

Based on our discoveries, we have also determined that for every month you do not perform an in depth automated vendor credit review you risk  losing $63,000 per billion dollars of spend with no chance of recovering it.  While $63,000 may not be a huge amount for you, if you spend multiple billions of dollars, and delay just a quarter’s time, that $63,000 figure becomes a large sum of money.

If you have any more questions about our benchmarking survey please join the conversation…

Our Latest News: Recovery Audit Technology Leader Lavante Continues Record Growth

Saturday, April 24th, 2010

On Wednesday, we released a straight forward news story about our Q1 success: Recovery Audit Technology Leader Lavante Continues Record Growth.   The story reported that we are growing quickly and that we are moving to a new larger facilty in San Jose.  The story was very direct and did not elaborate on too many details.   I was suprised by a volume of incoming emails and calls asking for more details.  On Wednesday alone I heard from three clients and three reporter/analysts.  More emails and calls continue to make there way in… 

I’d like to elaborate a little bit more on the story for the Lavante watchers in the audience.   Our new grade A facility is in the Santa Teresa area of San Jose and the property manger tells me it is over 26,000 square feet!  I do not want to risk a blister trying to walk through and measure it myself.  We plan to have our entire operation moved over in a couple months, but we are in the middle of three major trade events in the next month and we are rolling out a brand new product in three weeks so some of us are having a hard time packing our boxes.  (uh-oh… more phone call and emails from that “new product” teaser I am sure)

Regarding new business… how do I put this?  As the articles inicates, Q1 was a record quarter, but we’ve nearly already beat it in April alone.  Yes you read that correctly.  Clients are closing more quickly and they are growing larger in size…  In 2010 we have begun workng with three of the largest private companies in the U.S. and our new public clients are averaging a Fortune rating of F297.

I hope that answers any questions, but I am always available to discuss further.

Recovery Auditing Misconception #3 of 4

Friday, April 23rd, 2010

Recovery Auditing Misconception #3:  Profit Recovery is not a current Priority and I can afford to wait. 

The Short Answer

You may not be aware of it, but credits age and disappear over time. Once gone, they can’t be recovered. Our results show that delaying Lavante’s review could cost your company $62,500 per month for every billion dollars of your annualized spend. That’s for every month you delay. 

Why?

Lavante’s core product focuses on the AR balances of your vendors and discovers credits that you didn’t even know existed.  However, vendors are constantly reconciling and cleaning their AR records.  Unapplied credits have a “shelf-life:” as they age and go unclaimed, they’re applied by the vendor to offset unrelated disputed invoices or unearned discounts, or eventually written-off.  Unlike client AP records, there often isn’t a historic database that preserves ledger entries after they have been removed.  Thus, if a vendor removes a credit from their AR record, then it’s usually lost with no possibility of recovery. 

Lavante’s exhaustive benchmarking metrics point to a number of reasons why it is vital to begin the review immediately. 

  • Based on over a million data points, Lavante research suggests that after an open credit has aged over 90 days, you have less than a 20% chance of recovering that credit without third party intervention.  This subset of credits that age beyond 90 days accounts for potentially millions of dollars on an annual basis and should be part of your existing standards for managing working capital.
  • Lavante recovers for clients a consistent range of between $600,000 and $900,000 per every billion dollars in addressable spend. If not audited, this is the amount lost annually (see the figure below) due to vendor aging activity. This recovery history suggests that every month you delay reviewing these dynamic vendor records, you stand to lose $63,000 per billion dollars you spend (1/12th or 8% of your potential annual recovery opportunity).  

Accounts Payable Best Practices Closer Than You Think!

Sunday, April 11th, 2010

Accounts payable best practices are closer than you think.  Recently I was asked to help review a handful of workshop presentations that are going to presented at an upcoming association event.  I am not exactly an expert like the folks that submitted the presentations, but I could be counted on the make sure the proper format was being used and I spotted a couple typos along the way.  In my review I was struck by the high quality of material that was submitted (and will be presented).  My sample of presentations covered avoiding fraud; enterprise software upgrades, p-card programs, profit recovery auditing, staff development, among a few other items.

A thought occurred… it is very common for associations to sponsor events where a large volume of workshops are presented for pure peer-to-peer education purposes.  Sadly these presentations are one-time events, but the value they present is relevant for many months or years beyond the show at which they are featured.  I think folks in the AP field that are looking for answers and resources to help solve business problems can  rely on large associations.  Any person looking for material need only call into their preferred association and ask for the person that oversees education for the association and you will likely be connected with the person that oversees workshops, panel discussions and presentations.  That person will be connected to a number of professionals with very insightful things to say about nearly unlimited business issues.  In addition, that person will also know what the feedback is like about the speakers and can point you in the right direction.

Even if you do not attend national or regional events and you have not been exposed to peer-to-peer educational seminars you are still only a couple phone calls away from someone who has not only accomplished what you are attempting to do at work, they have become an expert on the subject and they are now trying to educate others.    Just remember that when you become the expert to return the favor.

Profit Recovery & Easter?

Saturday, April 3rd, 2010

What do Profit Recovery Firms and The Easter Bunny have in common?

When I was young on Easter morning my parents used to hide plastic eggs around the house with little surprises in them. Some eggs had candy. Some eggs contained dental floss in them (I didn’t care for those eggs so much) and some eggs contained money. (I liked those eggs the most)   As the youngest of four siblings by a couple years there were a few years when I was the only child still taking part in the hunt. The older kids had given up the hunt in favor of helping my folks prepare and hide the eggs. And boy did they get into it.  They hid more eggs in more ridiculous locations, but keep in mind that meant more money… and it was all mine.  I simply had to find it, and that was no small order.  I was now one person in search of four dozen eggs spread across the entire house. I remember one year in particular when I had searched for almost ten minutes and discovered only a single egg.   So… what did I do?

A) Look in a few obvious places find a small number of eggs and quit

B) Diligently go through the entire house and locate all of the eggs 

The same multiple choice can be applied to how you want your profit recovery audit firm to approach recovery. When the decision is about maximizing your cash flow recapture how can anyone settle on sampling as opposed to a steady and thorough approach. Every room, every corner counts.

If the moral of the story is not clear, traditonal AP recovery practices sampling, especially when reviewing vendor and supplier AR records.  Lavante has built a proprietary soaftware application that communicates with your entire population of vendors and maximizes recoveries for clients of all sizes across all industries.  That will buy your AP department a lot of chocolate eggs.

Happy Easter Everybody!

Recovery Audit Firms

Tuesday, March 30th, 2010

For those that are not familiar, Rich Lanaza has a great website called findmillions.net that discusses a number of aspects of  the recovery audit industry.  Specifically he has a few pages outlining the benefits of the services as well as the top questions people should ask when considering an audit.

Our own website will soon grow to include many of the things that Rich is doing for consumers.  For now you can see what is currently available at:  http://tinyurl.com/ydzgcbc

Recovery Audit Providers

Tuesday, March 30th, 2010

Updated:  In my humble opinion the Profit Recovery industry does not get enough credit (no pun) for the value they provide.  Analysts do not cover the space and most media outlets and publications glance over the topic. 

Before and since my original post I have made it a personal mission to reach out to different journals and periodicals in the AP space and challenge them to cover  recovery audit providers.  Many of us are newsmakers.  I have been quite pleased with the feedback and the growing coverage.  Sometimes it only requires a few friendly phone calls.

Admittedly the Profit Recovery industry may not be the most exciting, but it does offer a very direct value to clients.   Assume a Profit Recovery firm finds $100,000 for your company.  Consider what number of sales or what amount of effort would be required to generate that revenue.  In most cases, Profit Recovery delivers dollars to an enterprise with one of the most favorible ROI’s possible.

A few weeks ago PRG rang the bell at Nasdaq and as they are our primary competitor the occasion did not go unnoticed.  Rather than feel any envy, I was actually thrilled for them and for us as a result.  Any major publicity that they earn is easily translatable into publicity for the Profit Recovery space.  I still believe, based on overwhelming evidence from our audits, that recovery auditing is alive and well.  I am glad when that message is reinforced.

In one of my recent briefings with a fairly major analysts I was told that PRG’s decision to migrate slightly away from recovery makes the conversation more interesting.  A company like Lavante is investing in software to further tap into what we believe to be a rich recovery vein when other firms are moving slowly away.

The Power of the Software Demo

Tuesday, March 30th, 2010

I have noticed a pretty compelling trend as it relates to our sales cycle and trade shows. 

Most shows in the AP space place a heavy emphasis on attendee education and offer a number of tracks for everyone to attend and learn about the latest trends in the Accounts Payable.  All of these shows accept sponsorship from service providers and create a forum for professional in the space to interface with service providers to encourage education about service providers’ offerings.

The most common type of attendee/sponsor interaction is a tradeshow floor which as most of you know consists of colorful booths and clever give aways. Shows which offer these types of forums are very helpful and always fun.  Another type of interaction are the shows that, in favor of a tradeshow floor, offer a series of one-on-one meetings between professionals representing major corporations and service providers.  These shows are typically smaller and have a very different feel about them.

SO why am I bringing all this up?  In our business we usually experience a 120-150 day sales cycle.  That is to say, it takes about 4-5 months to meet a new company, educate them on our software products and begin doing business with them.  This average is actually good for our particular market, but it is certainly not the fastest sales cycle.

An interesting trend has been revealed; when we attend typical trade shows we close business in our average sales cycle, but when we attend shows with one-on-one meetings we drop our sales cycle down to 60-75 days.  In other words when we meet with buyers and show them our software on “day one” they buy from us in half the time.

It has ocurred to me that this particular blog may be better suited for a marketing blog, but I think this empirical data says a lot about the AP industry.  I believe professionals in this space are open to adopting new technology, but it is sometimes difficult to convince buyers that we have a new and unique approach.  A lot of providers are using the same phrases, ”faster,” “new techology,” more recoveries,” etc.   In most cases the first half of the 120-150 day sales cylce is convincing the buyer that we really are different.  When we finally get that point across and we earn the right to demonstrate our software… that is when the sale begins to accelerate.

Days Credits Outstanding – a new metric for managing cash flow

Thursday, March 18th, 2010

Days Sales Outstanding (DSO) and Days Payables Outstanding (DPO) are important, widely used metrics to manage working capital.  Financial managers monitor these statistics very closely and regard them as key performance indicators as they work to maximize overall cash flow as well as transactional efficiency.   Through our audit work communicating with extremely large numbers of vendors for Fortune 1000 enterprises, we have begun delivering significant value to our clients based on a new metric that measures and standardizes an important aspect of accounts payables financial efficiency – Days Credits Outstanding (DCO).   

DCO focuses on open credits that are typically not visible to your internal accounting personnel.  Specifically, these credits are aging on your vendors’ and suppliers’ receivables ledgers and, for a variety of reasons, may be outside of your books, or at least not specifically identified with the vendor.  DCO measures the amount of time that outstanding credits are open and available on your vendors’ accounts receivable records before you are able to actualize them as cash to your bottom line.  Allowing your DCO to grow means your cash inflow is being delayed. Given the time value of money, this represents lost cash, even if eventually you do recover the credits.

While aged vendor-side credits are sometimes known to your company, more often they’re not; they’re essentially unseen or lost dollars.  In fact, based on over a million data points, Lavante research indicates that after an open credit has aged over 90 days, you have less than a 20% chance of recovering that credit without third party intervention.   These “lost” dollars add up and can grow to a staggering one and a half million dollars per every billion dollars spent.  Tracking DCO enables your company to bring the management of these dollars in line with your existing standards for managing working capital.

In addition to cash timing implications, it is also important to consider the financial exposure that increased attention to DCO can reveal about your company.  A growing DCO is an indicator of risk because there is a proven likelihood of vendors using unreturned credits to offset unearned discounts and disputed invoices, or otherwise disposing of them as they age beyond a reasonable period.  Ultimately, unclaimed credits that are not used by the vendor are escheated, that is, turned over to the state.  In all of these scenarios, you are losing the cash forever.  A focus on DCO will help bring visibility to the dollars outstanding while driving the age of these items as low as the aging scope cut-off of your audit will allow.

The introduction of DCO as a key performance indicator is significant because it adds a new measurable element to cash management.   It encapsulates the fact that not only is it important to actualize all open credits, but it is also important to realize these dollars in the fastest time frame possible, thus maximizing cash flow.  The cash flow implications of DCO are as relevant to cash management as preventing early payments, or even taking all of your discounts. 

Lavante, with our unique ability to comprehensively collect and analyze vendor-side AR records and thus uncover these “lost” credits, is calculating the DCO metric as part of our audits.  Our clients use it to help them manage their cash flow and as a key indicator of the transactional efficiency of their accounts payables process.